Alternatives to Equity Compensation for Private Company Executives

Mar 05, 2020

Many of our clients face challenges attracting, motivating, and retaining top executives. To alleviate those challenges, most public companies have some kind of “equity-based” long-term incentive program (LTIP) in place for top executives. LTIPs reward executives for their contributions to value creation as measured by increases in share price. 

Although private companies face the same talent challenges as their public company counterparts, equity-based compensation is not prevalent among private company executives.

There are two primary alternatives to equity-based LTIPs: (1) phantom stock and (2) performance units. 

Phantom Stock

Phantom stock is similar to restricted stock. In this program, participants receive annual “phantom stock unit” grants. The initial unit value is based on the company’s book value, a formula, or as determined by an external valuation.

After the stock units vest, participants receive a cash payment equal to the full value of the units (plus any appreciation) times the number of units underlying the grant. Vesting can be time-based, tied to a participant’s retirement, or tied to a sale, merger, initial public offering (IPO), or other liquidity event.

Phantom stock is based on enterprise value creation and is typically not tied to individual performance goals. As is the case with restricted stock, as long as vesting criteria are met, phantom stock will always deliver value to the participant. Phantom stock encourages retention and provides a long-term performance orientation.

Performance Units

In this program, participants receive annual “performance unit” grants.

The initial unit value can be formula-based, tied to an external valuation, or assigned an arbitrary dollar value. Each grant has a three-year performance period.

Unlike phantom stock, individual and company performance goals provide the funding basis for performance units. Performance units are worth nothing if a threshold level of performance has not been attained; upside opportunity is possible (e.g., 150% of the initial unit value for maximum performance levels).

Participants receive a cash payment equal to the number of units underlying the award times the “per unit” value at the end of the performance period. In general, participants must be employed at the end of the performance period to receive an award.

The “overlapping” performance periods inherent in the program’s design encourage retention and provide a long-term performance orientation.


As you can see, the design features of each program type differ but either can be used to anchor the executive compensation program for private company executives.

Contact your Newport representative if you believe any of your clients might benefit from one of these cash-based LTIPs.

For Advisor Use Only

Copyright © 2015-2023 Newport Group, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Unauthorized access is prohibited. This site is designed for U.S. residents only.

Newport Group, Inc. and its affiliates provide recordkeeping, plan administration, trust and custody, consulting, fiduciary consulting, insurance and brokerage services. 

Investment Advisory and fiduciary consulting services are offered through Newport Group Consulting, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Securities are offered through Newport Group Securities, Inc., a dually-registered investment advisor and broker dealer, member FINRA. Securities in California are offered through Newport Securities Insurance Services. For more information about Newport Group Consulting and its services, Newport Group Securities, Inc. or Newport Securities Insurance Services and services offered, please refer to our Form ADV Part 2, which is available by contacting us at 407-333-2905, visit our website at, or  

Newport Trust Company is a New Hampshire state-chartered trust company Newport Trust Company provides independent fiduciary and trustee services for employee benefit plans.

Newport Group Consulting, LLC, Newport Group Securities, Inc., and Newport Trust Company are subsidiaries of Newport Group, Inc., an Ascensus Company.